Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Which Trading Strategy Is Better for Beginners

Introduction

If you’ve spent any time learning Forex or price action trading, you’ve probably come across two popular concepts: Turtle Body Soup and ICT (Inner Circle Trader). Both strategies focus on understanding price movement, liquidity, and market reversals, but they approach trading differently.

This leads to one of the most common questions among traders:

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Which Trading Strategy Is Better for Beginners?

The answer depends on what you’re looking for. Some traders enjoy studying dozens of concepts, while others prefer a structured strategy that is easier to learn, easier to execute, and easier to repeat consistently.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Turtle Body Soup vs ICT in detail, including:

• Learning difficulty
• Trading philosophy
• Liquidity concepts
• Market structure
• Entry confirmation
• Risk management
• Timeframes
• Advantages and disadvantages
• Which strategy suits beginners
• Which strategy suits experienced traders

By the end of this article, you’ll understand the strengths of both methods and why many traders are choosing CRT + Turtle Body Soup (CRT + TBS) as a practical way to trade today’s markets.

Learn CRT + TBS 

What Is Turtle Body Soup?

Before comparing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, it’s important to understand what Turtle Body Soup actually is.

Turtle Body Soup (TBS) is a price action trading strategy that focuses on identifying false breakouts, liquidity grabs, and high-probability market reversals. Instead of chasing breakouts, traders wait for the market to trap participants before looking for reversal opportunities.

Unlike many complex trading systems, Turtle Body Soup emphasizes reading candlestick behaviour and market intent through price action rather than relying on numerous indicators.

Many traders combine Turtle Body Soup with the CRT (Candlestick Reversal Theory) framework to create a structured trading plan.

The combination is widely known as CRT + TBS.

The idea is simple:

• Identify liquidity.
• Wait for market manipulation.
• Confirm the reversal.
• Enter with defined risk.
• Manage the trade systematically.

Because the rules are straightforward, many traders find CRT + TBS easier to learn than highly complex trading methodologies.

What Is ICT?

When discussing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, understanding ICT is equally important.

ICT stands for Inner Circle Trader, an educational methodology that teaches traders how institutions and smart money may interact with liquidity.

ICT includes concepts such as:

• Market Structure
• Liquidity Pools
• Fair Value Gaps (FVG)
• Order Blocks
• Breakers
• Mitigation Blocks
• Optimal Trade Entry (OTE)
• Premium and Discount Zones
• Dealing Range
• Kill Zones
• Judas Swing
• Liquidity Sweeps

Rather than being a single setup, ICT is an extensive educational framework containing many individual concepts.

Because of this, learning ICT often requires a significant investment of time and consistent chart study.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Core Philosophy

The biggest difference between Turtle Body Soup vs ICT lies in simplicity.

Turtle Body Soup aims to identify one clear trading opportunity after liquidity has been taken.

ICT teaches traders to understand the broader market narrative before entering a trade.

One focuses on practical execution.

The other focuses on understanding market mechanics from multiple perspectives.

Neither approach is inherently wrong.

However, many traders discover that simpler decision-making often leads to greater consistency.

Buy the CRT + Ebook

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Learning Curve

One of the first questions beginners ask is:

Which is easier to learn?

Turtle Body Soup

Most traders can understand the foundation within weeks.

Because the strategy follows a structured framework, traders spend more time practicing than memorizing dozens of concepts.

Learning typically focuses on:

• Liquidity
• Price action
• Confirmation
• Entries
• Risk management

Everything works together logically.

ICT

ICT contains a vast educational library.

Many traders spend months—or even years—studying concepts before feeling confident enough to execute consistently.

Topics include:

• Market Maker Models
• Dealing Ranges
• Daily Bias
• Kill Zones
• Session Timing
• Institutional Order Flow
• Fair Value Gaps
• Order Blocks
• Premium/Discount
• Liquidity Mapping

While extremely detailed, the sheer volume of material can feel overwhelming for beginners.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Simplicity

Trading becomes difficult when too many decisions must be made.

One reason traders compare Turtle Body Soup vs ICT is because they want a repeatable system.

Turtle Body Soup provides exactly that.

The checklist remains relatively straightforward:

1. Identify liquidity.
2. Wait for manipulation.
3. Confirm reversal.
4. Execute.
5. Manage risk.

ICT often requires traders to combine multiple concepts before entering.

For some traders this flexibility is beneficial.

For others, it creates analysis paralysis.

 

Market Structure Comparison

When comparing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, both strategies respect market structure.

However, they use it differently.

Turtle Body Soup

Market structure acts as confirmation.

Price manipulation followed by confirmation creates the trade opportunity.

The focus remains on high-probability reversals.

 

ICT

Market structure forms part of a much larger narrative.

Traders combine structure with:

• Fair Value Gaps
• Liquidity Pools
• Order Blocks
• Session Timing
• Institutional Flow

The analysis becomes more detailed.

Liquidity Concepts

Liquidity sits at the heart of both strategies.

This is why Turtle Body Soup vs ICT is such an interesting comparison.

Both believe markets frequently move toward liquidity before reversing.

However, they execute differently.

Turtle Body Soup

Liquidity is viewed as the trigger.

After liquidity has been taken, traders begin searching for reversal confirmation.

ICT

Liquidity represents only one component.

Traders often combine liquidity with multiple confirmation tools before entering.

 

Entry Confirmation

One of the biggest practical differences in Turtle Body Soup vs ICT is how traders enter positions.

Turtle Body Soup

Confirmation is usually based on:

• Price rejection
• Candlestick behaviour
• Market reaction
• CRT confirmation
• Turtle Body Soup setup

The rules remain relatively objective.

 

ICT

Confirmation may involve:

• Fair Value Gap entry
• Order Block reaction
• Optimal Trade Entry
• Session timing
• Premium or Discount pricing

This creates flexibility but also requires more interpretation.

 

Risk Management

No trading strategy succeeds without disciplined risk management.

Both Turtle Body Soup vs ICT encourage controlled risk.

Professional traders typically risk a small percentage of capital on each trade.

Regardless of strategy, consistency matters more than occasional large wins.

Many successful traders focus on protecting capital first and allowing profitable setups to play out over time.

 

Why Many Traders Prefer CRT + TBS

After comparing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, many traders eventually look for a framework that is easier to execute consistently.

This is where CRT + TBS becomes valuable.

CRT (Candlestick Reversal Theory) works alongside Turtle Body Soup by helping traders identify high-quality reversal confirmation after liquidity events.

Instead of relying on numerous overlapping concepts, traders can follow a structured process:

• Identify the setup.
• Wait for confirmation.
• Enter with predefined risk.
• Manage the position according to the trading plan.

This simplicity helps reduce emotional decision-making and creates a more repeatable routine. While every strategy requires practice and disciplined risk management, many traders appreciate that CRT + TBS offers a focused framework that is easier to follow than more expansive methodologies.

If you’d like to learn the complete CRT + TBS framework, including candlestick reversals and practical examples, you can explore the official ebook here:

Buy CRT + TBS ebook here

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Which Strategy Is Better for Beginners?

One of the biggest questions new traders ask is:

“Should I learn Turtle Body Soup or ICT first?”

The answer depends on your learning style and the amount of time you’re willing to dedicate to studying charts.

If you’re looking for a strategy with a clear set of rules that you can practise consistently, Turtle Body Soup is often the easier starting point. If you enjoy exploring many advanced concepts and building your own framework over time, ICT offers a much broader educational approach.

When comparing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, beginners should consider three important factors:

• Simplicity
• Consistency
• Execution

Many new traders lose money not because they lack intelligence, but because they constantly switch strategies. They watch one ICT video today, another Smart Money Concepts video tomorrow, and a completely different strategy next week. As a result, they never master one approach.

A structured framework like CRT + TBS encourages traders to focus on repeating the same process instead of chasing every new concept they see online.

 

Why Simplicity Matters in Trading

Professional traders often say:

“Simple systems are easier to execute consistently.”

That doesn’t mean simple trading is easy. Every strategy requires discipline, patience, and proper risk management.

However, reducing unnecessary complexity can help traders make decisions with greater confidence.

When comparing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, this is one of the biggest differences.

Turtle Body Soup

The workflow generally looks like this:

• Identify liquidity.
• Wait for manipulation.
• Wait for confirmation.
• Execute.
• Manage risk.

Everything follows a logical sequence.

ICT

An ICT trader may analyse:

• Higher-timeframe bias
• Market structure
• Liquidity
• Fair Value Gaps
• Order Blocks
• Premium/Discount arrays
• Kill Zones
• Session timing
• Optimal Trade Entry
• Institutional narrative

None of these concepts are necessarily wrong, but combining many variables can make decision-making more demanding, especially for newer traders.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Time Required to Learn

Another important comparison is learning time.

Turtle Body Soup

Most traders can begin practising the core concepts relatively quickly. The emphasis is on understanding price behaviour and recognising repeatable setups.

Many traders spend their time improving execution rather than continuously adding new concepts.

ICT

ICT is a comprehensive educational framework that includes many interconnected ideas. Learning it thoroughly often requires extensive study and chart review.

The exact learning time varies from person to person, but traders should expect a larger educational commitment.

When discussing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, this difference in scope is one of the main reasons traders compare the two.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Decision Making

Every trade is ultimately a decision.

The fewer unnecessary decisions a trader has to make, the easier it can be to remain disciplined.

With Turtle Body Soup, traders typically ask:

• Has liquidity been taken?
• Has price confirmed the reversal?
• Does the setup meet my trading plan?

If the answer is yes, they consider entering.

With ICT, traders may evaluate multiple additional factors before making a decision.

Neither approach guarantees profits. What matters is whether the trader can execute their chosen framework consistently over many trades.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Price Action Comparison

Both methods are based on price action.

Neither strategy depends on lagging indicators to generate trading signals.

The difference is in interpretation.

Turtle Body Soup

Price action is used to identify failed breakouts, liquidity grabs, and reversal opportunities.

The emphasis is on recognising when the market has likely trapped participants.

 

ICT

Price action is analysed through several additional institutional concepts, including liquidity mapping, order flow ideas, and structural models.

This broader interpretation can provide more context, but it also requires more analysis.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Risk Management

Regardless of which strategy you choose, poor risk management can quickly eliminate the advantages of a good setup.

Successful traders generally:

• Define risk before entering.
• Avoid increasing position size after losses.
• Use consistent position sizing.
• Accept that losing trades are part of trading.
• Focus on long-term consistency instead of individual trades.

A well-executed risk management plan is often more important than the choice between Turtle Body Soup vs ICT.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Trading Psychology

Psychology plays a significant role in trading success.

Many traders struggle because they:

• Enter too early.
• Exit too early.
• Move stop losses emotionally.
• Overtrade.
• Revenge trade after losses.

A structured process can help reduce emotional decision-making.

One reason some traders prefer CRT + TBS is that having a repeatable checklist can make it easier to avoid impulsive trades. However, no strategy can completely remove emotions—discipline must still come from the trader.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Which Strategy Fits Busy Traders?

Not everyone can spend hours studying charts every day.

Many traders have:

• Full-time jobs
• University commitments
• Businesses
• Family responsibilities

For these traders, a framework that is easier to review and repeat may be more practical.

This is one reason why many traders are attracted to CRT + TBS. Instead of continuously learning new concepts, they can focus on refining the same repeatable process over time.

 

Advantages of Turtle Body Soup

When comparing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, Turtle Body Soup offers several practical advantages:

• Easy to understand.
• Based on price action.
• Focuses on liquidity and reversals.
• Structured execution process.
• Suitable for beginners.
• Can be combined with CRT for additional confirmation.
• Encourages consistency.
• Less overwhelming for new traders.
• Works across multiple markets.
• Easy to build a trading routine around.

 

Advantages of ICT

ICT also offers several strengths:

• Extensive educational framework.
• Deep focus on market behaviour.
• Multiple analytical concepts.
• Flexible execution models.
• Strong emphasis on liquidity.
• Detailed understanding of institutional ideas.
• Can be adapted to different trading styles.
• Comprehensive educational content.

 

Turtle Body Soup vs ICT: Pros and Cons:

Turtle Body Soup	ICT
Easier to learn	Larger learning curve
Structured execution	More analytical flexibility
Beginner friendly	Requires more study
Repeatable process	Many interconnected concepts
Lower complexity	Higher complexity
Can reduce analysis paralysis	More interpretation required
Easy to combine with CRT	Broad educational framework

Common Mistakes Traders Make

Whether choosing Turtle Body Soup vs ICT, many traders make the same mistakes.

1. Strategy Hopping

Learning one strategy for two weeks before switching to another prevents meaningful progress.

2. Ignoring Risk Management

 Even a high-quality setup cannot overcome poor position sizing or emotional risk decisions.

3. Overtrading

 More trades do not necessarily lead to better results.

Waiting for high-quality setups is often more important than frequent trading.

4. Chasing Every New Concept

 Markets constantly produce new ideas and terminology.

Many traders benefit more from mastering one structured approach than from collecting dozens of unrelated concepts.

5. Skipping Practice

  Reading articles is helpful, but consistent chart review and practice are essential for improving execution.

Why Many Traders Transition to CRT + TBS?

After exploring different methodologies, many traders eventually realise that consistency matters more than complexity.

CRT + TBS combines:

• Liquidity understanding
• Candlestick reversal confirmation
• Structured execution
• Defined risk management
• Repeatable decision-making

Rather than attempting to analyse every possible market variable, traders can focus on executing a clear trading plan.

This does not mean one strategy is universally “better” than another. Different traders succeed with different methods. However, for traders who value simplicity and repeatability, CRT + TBS offers a practical framework that many find easier to implement consistently.

To learn more about CRT + TBS buy the ebook